A metal lunchbox hits the counter with a hollow clang. Some lunches were delicious, others were a soggy disaster, and a few would raise eyebrows today. How many of these 26 old-school lunches do you remember?
#26 Bologna on Soft White Bread
The smell came first when you unwrapped it. Bologna, white bread, and a little warm mustard was one of my favourites. The bread stuck to the meat where the package moisture had soaked through. A leaf of lettuce looked crispy at breakfast and limp by lunch.
Back then, nobody thought much about a sandwich sitting in a warm lunchbox for hours. The USDA's FoodKeeper guidance recommends refrigerating perishable foods at 40°F or below, something our old metal lunchboxes certainly couldn't manage.
I'd still happily eat a bologna sandwich today, although I'd pack it differently. Keep it cold in an insulated bag with frozen cold sources, and pack the lettuce separately. Nobody wants soggy bread, no matter how nostalgic the sandwich is.
#25 The Sandwich in a Metal Lunchbox
The box had a handle stout enough for a schoolyard fight and a latch that pinched fingers. It kept my sandwich from being crushed. It did nothing to cool the sandwich.
Remember how hot those metal boxes could get? A lunchbox left beside a classroom heater might feel like it had spent the morning in the sun. Its solid sides offered no clue about the food's temperature.
We loved those lunchboxes for their colorful designs, not their cooling abilities. For perishable sandwiches today, the USDA recommends an insulated bag with at least two cold sources placed around the food.
The old box still has a job on a shelf, holding the little things you don't want to lose. I wouldn't trust it with my lunch anymore, though.
Quick check
- 40°F or below: the cold-storage target.
- Two cold sources: the USDA's lunch-packing advice for perishables.
- Warm lunchbox wall: no proof that the food inside stayed cold.
#24 Milk Cartons in the Lunch Line
Who remembers wrestling with those little milk cartons? Finding the folded corner that would open without collapsing was practically a lunchtime skill. And when it went wrong, you ended up with milk everywhere.
School milk was usually kept chilled before serving, but milk packed from home was another story. A carton pulled from the refrigerator before the bus arrived needed cold storage until lunch.
Today, I'd pack refrigerated milk with frozen cold sources or choose an unopened shelf-stable carton. The latter doesn't need refrigeration until opened, but always check the packaging.
And if you still remember how to open those old cartons without spilling anything, I'm officially impressed!
#23 Egg Salad Under the Waxed Paper
Egg salad traveled badly in waxed paper. It squeezed past the bread when you bit down, then left a yellow stain on the napkin. By lunchtime, my sandwich was usually squashed, and the wrapper smelled even worse by the final bell. You know exactly the smell I'm talking about.
The funny thing is, I still love egg salad. I just wouldn't leave it sitting in a warm lunchbox today. The FDA recommends refrigerating cooked eggs and egg dishes promptly.
Pack egg salad cold in a sealed container and keep the bread separate until lunchtime. A little mustard and celery add some crunch, too.
And don't forget to wash that container afterward. Dried egg salad is nobody's idea of fun.
Still love egg salad sandwiches? Try this: Instant Pot Egg Salad (Keto, Gluten-Free)
#22 Peanut Butter and Jelly Every Day
Peanut butter and jelly survived my school morning better than egg salad. It held together after a trip under a stack of heavy books. It was filling, sweet, and one of those sandwiches I never seemed to get tired of. I still love a good PB&J today.
Of course, things are different in schools now. Peanut allergies can be serious, so check school rules and children's allergies before packing one. The CDC's food allergy guidance recommends avoiding known allergens in school settings.
If peanuts are allowed, spread the jelly between thin layers of peanut butter to slow the bread from getting soggy. It's a little trick I wish I'd known back then.
Were you a peanut butter and jelly kid, or did you always hope for something else?
#21 Buttered Bread Wrapped Beside an Apple
Some lunches were a butter sandwich and a piece of fruit. The apple rolled around inside the box, bruising one side of the bread, and somehow everything ended up tasting faintly of apple.
It wasn't fancy, but sometimes plain buttered bread was exactly what you wanted. The trouble was that it didn't always keep you full until the last bell.
I'd still eat it today, but I'd add something more filling. A hard-boiled egg works if kept cold, while roasted chickpeas are another option.
Sometimes the simplest lunches are the ones we remember most.
#20 Tuna Salad in a Thermos Cap
That little plastic cap looked like a bowl. It held a few spoonfuls of tuna salad, which seemed clever until you had to dig it out with a short spoon. And if you spilled any, that fishy smell followed you for the rest of the afternoon.
The problem was that the cap wasn't insulated like the thermos itself. Tuna salad needs refrigeration, so a sealed container packed with frozen cold sources is a much better choice.
Before mixing, press the tuna lightly with a fork to get rid of excess liquid. A little pickle or lemon adds flavor, and keeping crackers separate stops them from turning soggy.
I still like tuna salad, but I'd happily leave the thermos-cap dining experience in the past.
#19 Celery Sticks Filled With Cheese Spread
A rib of celery held bright orange cheese spread neatly until somebody sat on the lunchbox. Then the filling flattened into the grooves, and the celery bent instead of snapping.
Those bright orange cheese-filled celery sticks were really popular. Maybe it was the crunchy celery, or perhaps we just loved anything filled with cheese.
They're still an easy snack to make. Wash and dry the celery, then pack the spread separately in a chilled container if refrigeration is required.
Let everyone fill their own celery at lunchtime. It's much less messy, although squeezing cheese into those little grooves was half the fun.
You might also like27 Rules Every Mother Enforced at the Dinner Table in 1965
#18 Homemade Custard in a Glass Jar
A small jar of custard was a huge hit. The spoon clinked against the glass, and the last bite hid in the curve at the bottom. I always looked forward to finding something homemade and sweet in my lunchbox.
The downside? Glass jars weren't exactly ideal for children carrying lunchboxes around all day. And homemade custard needed to stay cold.
Today, I'd divide custard into shallow containers, refrigerate it promptly, and pack a portion with frozen cold sources.
I'd save the glass jar for eating custard at home. There's something about scraping out that last spoonful that I still love.
#17 Candy Cigarettes Beside the Sandwich
Can you imagine a child bringing candy cigarettes to school today? Yet back then, those little white sticks were a perfectly ordinary treat.
They made candy look like cigarettes. We'd hold them between our fingers, pretending to be grown-ups, without thinking twice about it. Even the packaging looked like a real cigarette pack.
Looking back, it's one of those childhood trends that seems completely bizarre now.
I'd rather tuck a cookie or piece of chocolate into a lunchbox these days. Still, I bet plenty of people remember those candy cigarettes. Did you pretend to smoke them, too?
#16 Frozen Orange Drink Concentrate as Ice
A frozen can of orange drink concentrate had a second job before anyone opened it. It sat against the lunch and thawed while the school day moved along. By lunchtime, you hoped the can had kept everything cool enough to eat.
It seemed like a clever trick, but a cold can didn't guarantee the sandwich beside it was safe. The USDA recommends proper frozen cold sources for perishable lunches.
I'd use ice packs today and save the orange concentrate for making a pitcher of juice at home.
Still, I remember how satisfying it was to mix that thick concentrate with water and watch it turn into a bright orange drink.
#15 Sardines Packed in a Small Tin
A sardine tin was sturdy and compact. It also required a place to drain the oil, somewhere to put the lid, and a child willing to smell fishy throughout the afternoon. Not exactly the easiest lunch to eat at a school desk.
Sardines were convenient because unopened shelf-stable tins didn't need refrigeration. Once opened, however, leftovers need to go into a covered container in the fridge.
I still enjoy sardines on toast with a squeeze of lemon, but I'd much rather eat them at home.
Some foods taste better when you have a proper plate, a fork, and nobody sitting beside you complaining about the smell.
#14 Vienna Sausages With Their Little Key
Who remembers opening those little tins with the tiny metal key? You turned it around the rim, pulling off a thin strip of metal. It was weirdly satisfying until the key slipped or the metal edge caught your finger.
Vienna sausages were popular because they were cheap, convenient, and required almost no preparation. An unopened shelf-stable can could travel easily, although the package directions still mattered.
I'd rather open the tin at home these days, heat the sausages in a pan, and serve them with something crunchy.
But I have to admit that little metal key was probably more memorable than the sausages themselves.
#13 Deviled Eggs on a Paper Plate
At church hall lunches, deviled eggs appeared in a ring on a paper plate. Getting them to school in one piece was another matter. Every bump on my bicycle threatened the filling. By lunchtime, the paprika was on the lid, and the eggs looked more like scrambled eggs.
I still love deviled eggs, but I'd never transport them on a paper plate again.
Use a lidded container that holds the halves snugly, and pack it with frozen cold sources. Dry the cooked egg whites before filling them, and add a little pickle brine for extra flavor.
For a school lunch without reliable refrigeration, though, I'd choose something else.
You might also remember: 27 Candy and Snacks From the 1970s That Taste Different Now, and Why
#12 Cold Spaghetti in a Plastic Bag
Leftover spaghetti went into whatever bag was clean. The noodles pressed into a solid block, and the sauce colored the plastic orange. If there was no way to heat it, you either ate cold spaghetti or tried your luck at the lunch table trading it.
I can't say cold, clumped-together spaghetti was ever my favorite.
These days, I'd pack leftovers in a proper container and keep them refrigerated until needed. The USDA recommends storing cooked leftovers for three to four days at 40°F or below and reheating them to 165°F.
A shallow container helps pasta cool faster, while a little extra sauce keeps it from drying out.
And if there's a microwave available, use a microwave-safe container, stir during reheating, and check that the center reaches 165°F.
You might also remember: 27 Foods Grandmothers Make That Mothers Won't Allow
#11 Marshmallow Fluff Between Two Bread Slices
The bread peeled away from the filling in long, sticky threads. By lunch, a fluff sandwich had pressed flat beneath the apple, but it still tasted exactly like the treat you hoped to find.
Face it, marshmallow fluff between two slices of bread was more of a dessert than a decent lunch. But as a child, that was probably why I loved it.
The problem was that it didn't keep you full for very long. You'd finish your sweet sandwich and be hungry again before the afternoon was over.
I'd still make one occasionally, but I'd serve it with something more filling. And I'd definitely pack extra napkins.
Some childhood favorites are worth keeping as treats rather than everyday meals.
#10 Pimento Cheese Pressed Into White Bread
Pimento cheese stained the bread orange at the edges. It was creamy, slightly tangy, and delicious when freshly made. Unfortunately, a few hours in a warm lunchbox could leave you with soggy bread and a rather unpleasant sandwich.
This is one old favorite I'd happily bring back.
Drain chopped pimentos before stirring them into the cheese. Spread the filling between slices of sturdy bread, then chill the finished sandwich before packing. Keep it cold with frozen cold sources.
For something even better, toast the bread in a cast-iron pan and add the cheese while it's still warm.
Just taste before adding salt. Cheese and pickles already bring plenty of it.
You might also like27 Things People Over 60 Still Do With Leftovers That Food-Safety Experts Beg Them to Stop
#9 Powdered Fruit Drink in a Thermos
The cap came off pink. So did the inside of the thermos, the napkin, and the ring around a child's mouth. Those brightly colored powdered drinks seemed to stain absolutely everything.
And if you were allowed to mix your own, chances are you added far more powder than the instructions suggested.
I'd still make one occasionally for the memories, but I'd mix it at home and pack a smaller portion.
Don't forget to wash the thermos lid and gasket afterward. Sweet residue can hide in those little grooves and encourage bacterial growth.
Of course, plain water is a perfectly good alternative, even if it isn't nearly as exciting as a bright pink drink.
#8 Chicken Soup in a Glass Thermos
The glass-lined thermos made a faint clink when you set it down. It seemed sturdy enough, but one hard fall could break the glass liner inside.
Chicken soup was a wonderful lunch on a cold day, especially when your mom had made it the night before. The challenge was keeping it hot until lunchtime.
Today, I'd use an insulated stainless steel food jar. Preheat it with boiling water, empty it carefully, and fill it with steaming-hot soup. The USDA recommends keeping hot food at 140°F or above.
Reheat leftover soup to 165°F before packing, and cook raw chicken to the same temperature.
A modern thermos makes the whole thing easier, although I'd still check the manufacturer's instructions for keeping food hot safely.
You might also remember: 25 Things Every 1970s Kitchen Had That Your Grandchildren Have Never Seen
#7 Cookies Traded Across the Lunch Table
A cookie from home once changed hands for a bag of chips without the blink of an eye. So did an unwanted sandwich. Lunchroom trading was practically its own little economy.
If somebody brought homemade chocolate chip cookies, you knew they had something valuable. And if you had a sandwich you didn't like, you hoped somebody else would want it.
Of course, food allergies make trading much riskier today. The CDC recommends that schools have plans to protect children with food allergies.
If you're baking cookies for a grandchild, check the school's rules and keep ingredient information from packaged add-ins.
I do miss those lunchtime trades, though. What was the one thing in your lunchbox everyone wanted?
#6 Roast Beef Left Over From Sunday
Sunday's roast made Monday sandwiches feel grand. I remember being one of the most popular kids on the playground whenever I brought leftover roast beef. Everyone suddenly seemed invested in trading lunches.
The secret to a good roast beef sandwich was thin slices, fresh bread, and just enough mustard.
Today, I'd refrigerate the cooked beef promptly and keep the sandwich cold with frozen cold sources. The USDA recommends using refrigerated cooked leftovers within three to four days.
Slice the beef across the grain so it doesn't pull the bread apart, and keep wet mustard or horseradish separate until lunchtime.
I'd still choose leftover Sunday roast over plenty of modern lunch options.
You might also remember: 26 Things in Your Fridge Right Now That Should Have Been Thrown Out
#5 Liverwurst With Mustard and Onion
Liverwurst had a smell that announced lunch before you opened the wrapper. Spread thin with mustard and a few onion slices, it had devoted fans and no middle ground in a classroom.
You either loved liverwurst or couldn't understand why anyone would willingly eat it. I don't remember many children being undecided.
It's still a perfectly reasonable sandwich filling if you enjoy it, but it needs refrigeration. Keep it cold and follow the package's storage directions.
For better texture, spread it on cooled toasted rye bread with a little mustard. Hot toast can melt the fat and make everything greasy.
And if you're packing lunch for somebody else, I'd definitely ask before surprising them with liverwurst..
#4 Potato Salad in a Lunchbox Cup
Potato salad slipped into a little cup with a lid that never seemed to seat right. The fork went through the potatoes, the cup tipped, and suddenly your entire lunchbox smelled like vinegar and onions.
I love potato salad, but those flimsy little containers were never a good idea.
The problem wasn't simply the mayonnaise. Cooked potatoes and prepared potato salad need cold storage, regardless of the dressing.
Cool the potatoes promptly, then add the dressing once they stop steaming. Taste for salt and acidity before adding more mayonnaise.
A leakproof container and frozen cold sources make potato salad much easier to pack. And thankfully, you won't spend the afternoon smelling like onions.
You might also remember: 27 Things Your Grandmother Kept in Her Kitchen That Nobody Keeps Now
#3 Whole Carrots Dug Out of the Garden
A whole carrot pulled from the soil looked ready to eat after a quick rub on your shirt. If you grew up eating vegetables straight from the garden, you probably remember that gritty crunch.
We didn't always think twice about brushing off the dirt and taking a bite. Looking back, a proper wash would have been a much better idea.
Rinse carrots under running water and scrub them with a clean vegetable brush. The FDA recommends washing produce before peeling, too.
Dry them before packing, or cut them into sticks using a clean knife and cutting board. The crunch is worth keeping. The dirt between your teeth isn't.
#2 Frozen Pudding Pops in Waxed Paper
A homemade pudding pop left the freezer frozen and arrived at school as a soft packet. By lunchtime, you were lucky if it still looked like a frozen treat.
I remember how quickly the chocolate spread everywhere. The spoon, the wrapper, the sandwich, and sometimes even your clothes ended up covered.
Frozen pudding pops were delicious, but they weren't reliable ice packs for the rest of your lunch. Perishable foods still need proper frozen and cold sources.
I'd save homemade pudding pops for an afternoon treat instead. Pour cooled pudding into molds, freeze until firm, and briefly run the outside under water to release them.
They're still worth making, just preferably somewhere you can wash your hands afterward.
#1 The Uneaten Sandwich Sent Back Tomorrow
A sandwich came home untouched, so it went back out the next morning. The wrapper was still neat. After all, why waste a perfectly good-looking sandwich?
I suspect more than a few families did this without thinking twice. Unfortunately, nobody knew how warm that sandwich had become during the previous school day.
If a perishable sandwich spent hours without dependable cold storage, it's safer to throw it away. A clean wrapper and a normal smell don't tell you whether the filling stayed at a safe temperature.
Why didn't the child eat it? Was the bread soggy? Did lunch start too late? Was the filling something the child had already said they didn't like?
Sometimes the answer is as simple as packing something they actually enjoy.
Prepare a fresh sandwich, keep it refrigerated, and pack it with frozen cold sources the next morning.
Some old lunchbox habits are worth remembering, but this definitely isn't one I'd bring back.
Keep reading
27 Things That Were Always on the Table in the 1960s and Never Are Now
See all 27 →
More you’ll remember
24 Casseroles That Fed America in 1975 and Disappeared Without a Funeral
27 Dishes From Church Suppers That Nobody Makes Anymore
27 Old-Fashioned Desserts That Deserve a Comeback
The Bottom Line
Those 1960s lunches were built around a sturdy box, food a child would eat, and a rushed morning. The weak point was the stretch between the refrigerator and the lunch bell.
You already know how much easier morning feels when the containers are clean, the cold sources are frozen, and the sandwich choice is settled. Keep the foods you loved; change how they travel.
I'd love to know which of these 1960s school lunches you remember most. Was there something your mom packed that you absolutely loved, or something you couldn't stand? Tell me in the comments!
Leave a Reply